Join us at The Whalies • April 10th
Get Your Ticket
Breaking Down the Ecommerce Giants: BigCommerce vs. Shopify - Picking the Winner

Breaking Down the Ecommerce Giants: BigCommerce vs. Shopify - Picking the Winner

Last Updated:  
March 18, 2024

Welcome to the big leagues of ecommerce, where the battle for supremacy rages on.

In the left corner, we have BigCommerce, a heavyweight contender with a knack for knocking out the competition.

In the right corner, we've got Shopify, the agile, tech-savvy champ that's been making waves. This is the showdown you've all been waiting for – BigCommerce vs. Shopify!

Before we dive headfirst into the fray, let's establish the importance of choosing the right ecommerce platform. According to recent statistics from Statista, global ecommerce sales are projected to reach a staggering $8.1 trillion by 2026. That's a whole lot of zeroes!

So, picking the right platform can mean riding the wave of success or sinking like a brick in the digital ocean.

Now, let's get ready to rumble as we introduce you to the contenders, BigCommerce vs. Shopify!


bigcommerce vs shopify


Understanding BigCommerce

BigCommerce is the wise old sage of the ecommerce world – experienced, versatile, and ready for action. Here's what makes it a formidable opponent:

Responsive and Customizable Themes

In the age of online window shopping, first impressions count.

According to a recent study by Adobe, 38% of online shoppers will stop engaging with a website if the content or layout is unattractive.

BigCommerce knows this and offers a plethora of responsive and customizable themes, ensuring your ecommerce store looks so good it practically sells itself.

Robust Product Management System

Managing your product catalog should be as smooth as butter, and BigCommerce understands that. BigCommerce's robust product management system ensures you're always on top of your inventory, no matter how extensive or diverse it is.

Advanced SEO Capabilities

Search engine optimization (SEO) is the secret sauce for getting your online store noticed in the vast digital wilderness.

According to a report by Backlinko, the first result in Google's organic search results gets an average click-through rate of 27.6%. As an ecommerce platform, BigCommerce equips you with advanced SEO tools to help you climb the rankings and claim that coveted top spot.

Built-In Marketing Tools

Marketing is the heartbeat of ecommerce. Without it, your online store is just a well-kept secret. BigCommerce comes to the rescue with built-in marketing tools that cover everything from email campaigns to social media integration.

You won't need a separate marketing department – it's all right here.

Integrations and Third-Party Apps

In a world where every business is unique, one-size-fits-all solutions just won't cut it.

BigCommerce knows this, which is why it plays nice with others. A recent study by Salesforce found that companies integrating their ecommerce and CRM systems saw an average increase in sales productivity by 35%. BigCommerce's array of integrations and third-party apps lets you tailor your store to your specific needs, without breaking a sweat.

Unveiling Shopify

Shopify, our nimble ninja in this ecommerce showdown, is renowned for its user-friendliness and impressive features. Let's see what it's got up its sleeve:

User-friendly interface and Drag-and-Drop Functionality

Shopify's user interface is so intuitive that even your grandma could set up a store. A recent 2023 data by Baymard Institute found that 63% of consumers abandoned their shopping carts due to a complicated checkout process. With Shopify's drag-and-drop functionality and the various eye-catching Shopify themes, you'll have your store up and running faster than you can say "cha-ching!"

Extensive App Store and Integrations

Shopify's app store is the Willy Wonka's Chocolate Factory of ecommerce. Whether you need a new payment gateway or an AI-powered chatbot, there's an app for it. The more tools you have in your toolkit, the more powerful your store becomes.

Mobile Commerce and Point-of-Sale Capabilities

Mobile commerce is the present and the future. According to a study by Statista, 74% of all ecommerce traffic in Q1 2023 came from smartphones. Shopify doesn't just offer mobile commerce capabilities; it excels in them.

And if you're thinking of dipping your toes into physical retail, Shopify's point-of-sale feature or Shopify POS has you covered.

SEO and Marketing Features

Shopify is more than just a pretty face; it's got the brains too. Its SEO and marketing features are designed to help you conquer the digital battlefield.

Order Management and Fulfillment Options

Shopify's order management system is like having a personal assistant for your store. It streamlines order processing, making your life easier and your customers happier. After all, a recent survey by PwC found that 73% of consumers highlight experience as an important factor in their purchasing decisions.

Comparing Pricing and Plans

In the ecommerce ring, your budget is your cornerman, and you need to make every dollar count. Let's dissect the pricing structures of BigCommerce vs. Shopify to see which one packs the best punch for your wallet.

Analyzing the Different Plans and Their Corresponding Features

BigCommerce and Shopify both offer a range of plans tailored to your needs. Whether you're a small fish in a big pond or a giant among minnows, there's a plan that suits your budget and ambitions.

BigCommerce Plans

BigCommerce offers a quartet of plans, each designed to cater to different stages of your ecommerce journey. Let's break them down:

  1. Standard Plan ($29/month): Priced at a competitive rate, it offers a robust set of features, including unlimited products, staff accounts, and unlimited bandwidth. It's your first stepping stone to ecommerce greatness.
  2. Plus Plan ($79/month): As your business grows, so do your needs. The Plus Plan is tailored for businesses in the growth phase. It builds upon the Standard Plan with additional features like abandoned cart recovery, customer segmentation, and stored credit card information for returning customers.
  3. Pro Plan ($299/month): When you're ready to play with the big boys and girls of ecommerce, the Pro Plan is your ticket. This plan is designed for established businesses with high-volume sales. It adds Google Customer Reviews, product filtering, and advanced product search, taking your store's functionality to the next level.
  4. BigCommerce Enterprise: The BigCommerce Enterprise plan is the heavyweight champion of ecommerce solutions, designed for large businesses and enterprise-level merchants. To learn more about its features, you have to contact their customer support.

Shopify Plans

Both BigCommerce and Shopify offer a quartet of plans to cater to your ecommerce needs. Let's dissect the plans for the Shopify ecommerce platform:

  1. Basic Shopify ($25/month): If you're just starting and want a cost-effective solution, Basic Shopify is your go-to plan. It provides all the essentials you need to set up and run a Shopify store, including an online store, a blog, and basic reporting.
  2. Shopify ($65/month): As your business grows and you need more advanced features, the standard Shopify plan steps in. This plan includes everything from Basic Shopify, plus additional features such as professional reports and the ability to offer up to five staff accounts.
  3. Advanced Shopify ($399/month): For high-growth businesses, the Advanced Shopify plan offers even more firepower. You get everything from the Shopify plan, along with advanced report building, third-party calculated shipping rates, and the ability to offer up to 15 staff accounts.
  4. Shopify Plus ($2000/month): When you've ascended to the ecommerce Olympus and require enterprise-level solutions, Shopify Plus is the crown jewel. It's a fully customizable and scalable solution tailored for large businesses and high-volume merchants.

Considering Transaction Fees and Credit Card Rates

Both BigCommerce and Shopify come with their own sets of costs, and you don't want any surprises lurking in the shadows.

Transaction Fees

BigCommerce doesn't play the nickel-and-dime game. It doesn't charge any transaction fees on any of its plans. That's right, folks – you keep what you earn, no questions asked.

Shopify, on the other hand, does have transaction fees, but they're on a sliding scale depending on your plan. The higher your plan, the lower your fees. Keep in mind that if you use Shopify Payments (their in-house payment gateway), you can kiss those transaction fees goodbye.

Credit Card Rates

Here's where the rubber meets the road. Credit card rates can eat into your profits faster than you can say "cha-ching." BigCommerce offers competitive credit card rates (around (2.59% + $0.49 per transaction), and the best part is that they don't discriminate based on your plan. It's a level playing field for all.

Shopify, once again, adjusts its credit card rates based on your plan. The higher your plan, the lower the rates. So, if you're playing the long game, you might want to consider the bigger plans for those sweet, sweet savings, especially when you are generating large sales volumes.

Design and Customization

Recent research done by Lindgaard et al. found that users judge a website's credibility in just 0.05 seconds. That's faster than the blink of an eye! Therefore, your store's aesthetics matter. It's like the digital version of curb appeal.

Exploring the Design Options and Themes Available on BigCommerce

BigCommerce doesn't want you to just have a store; it wants you to have a store that makes jaws drop. When it comes to BigCommerce themes and design options, BigCommerce has got your back. You'll find a rich selection of professionally designed themes that can give your BigCommerce store a sleek and polished look right out of the box. These themes cover various industries and styles, so whether you're selling fashion, electronics, or artisanal hot sauce, there's a theme that'll suit your brand's personality.

Analyzing the Design Flexibility and Customization Capabilities of Shopify

Shopify isn't just a pretty face; it's also a creative playground for aspiring designers and seasoned pros alike. When it comes to design flexibility, Shopify stands tall. You can choose from a wide array of professionally designed themes, both free and paid, to give your store a unique look.

But here's the real magic – you can dive deep into the HTML and CSS of your store, giving you the power to customize every pixel if you so desire. Plus, with a bustling community of developers and designers, you can always find a helping hand with an ecommerce partner if you want to take your store's design to the next level.

Comparing the Ease of Use and Flexibility for Non-Technical Users

Not everyone speaks fluent binary code, and that's perfectly okay in the world of ecommerce. Both BigCommerce and Shopify understand that user-friendliness is the name of the game, even if you'd rather wield a magic staff than a keyboard.

Shopify, in particular, has earned its stripes as a user-friendly platform. Its intuitive interface, drag-and-drop functionality, and extensive help center make it a breeze for non-technical users to set up shop without breaking a sweat.

BigCommerce, too, is no slouch in this department, offering user-friendly features and a gentle learning curve.

Ecommerce Functionality

When it comes to ecommerce functionality, both BigCommerce and Shopify pack a punch. Let's take a closer look at what they bring to the table.

Product Management and Inventory Tracking

BigCommerce shines when it comes to managing your products and keeping tabs on your inventory. It offers a user-friendly interface that allows you to easily add and edit product listings. Plus, it supports various product types, making it suitable for businesses with diverse offerings. When it comes to inventory tracking, BigCommerce provides real-time updates, ensuring you never oversell or run out of stock unexpectedly.

Payment Gateway Options

BigCommerce gives you the flexibility to choose from a wide range of payment gateways. Whether you prefer PayPal, Stripe, Square, or other popular options, BigCommerce has you covered. This variety ensures you can offer your customers their preferred payment methods, boosting conversions and customer satisfaction.

Shipping and Fulfillment Capabilities

Shipping can make or break the ecommerce experience, and BigCommerce understands this. It offers a comprehensive suite of shipping and fulfillment features. You can calculate shipping rates, print labels, and even offer real-time shipping quotes to customers. Plus, BigCommerce integrates seamlessly with major carriers like UPS and FedEx, making order fulfillment a breeze.

Analyzing the Ecommerce Capabilities Provided by Shopify

Shopify also packs a punch too and when it comes to ecommerce functionality, Shopify stands tall.

Product Catalog Management

Shopify is a master at helping you organize and display your products. It offers a user-friendly dashboard where you can effortlessly add and manage products and schedule any product launches. Plus, its robust product categorization and tagging system ensures that your customers can easily find what they're looking for, even if you have an extensive catalog.

Payment and Checkout Options

Shopify's payment options are like a smorgasbord for e-commerce entrepreneurs. From its in-house payment gateway, Shopify Payments, to a vast selection of third-party payment gateways, you'll have plenty of choices. This variety ensures that your customers can pay in their preferred way, reducing cart abandonment rates.

Shipping and Order Fulfillment Features

Shopify streamlines the entire shipping process for you. It provides built-in shipping tools that allow you to set custom shipping rates, print shipping labels, and even offer real-time shipping quotes to your customers. Furthermore, its partnership with major carriers simplifies order fulfillment, whether you're shipping domestically or internationally.

SEO and Marketing Tools

BigCommerce knows the importance of being seen, so it comes prepared with a toolbox of SEO capabilities. You'll find customizable URLs, meta tags, and header tags that are as flexible as a yoga instructor. Want search engines to adore your site? BigCommerce generates XML sitemaps to ensure they can navigate it with ease.

But that's not all. BigCommerce wants you to be the marketing maestro of your ecommerce symphony. It offers integrated marketing tools like email marketing and product recommendations.

Similarly, Shopify is no stranger to the SEO and marketing game either. It's like the cool kid who knows all the latest tricks. You can customize title tags, meta descriptions, and URL structures for your products and pages. Oh, and Shopify isn't just a shopping cart – it's a content powerhouse too. With its built-in blog functionality, you can create content that draws organic traffic like a magnet.

And if you thought the party was over, think again. Shopify doesn't want you to lose out on potential sales, so it offers features like abandoned cart recovery, email marketing, and social media integration.

Stay On Top of Your SEO & Marketing Efforts With Summary

But wait, there's more! In the ever-evolving world of ecommerce, keeping track of your metrics is as crucial as choosing the right theme for your store. That's where the Triple Whale Summary dashboard swoops in to save the day. It seamlessly integrates with your preferred ecommerce platform and marketing channels, creating a visual dashboard that brings all your metrics together.

With centralized metrics, you can easily view your ad spend and return on ad spend (ROAS) across your key ad platforms, gaining a holistic understanding of your business growth. It's like having a command center at your fingertips.

Learn More About Summary Today!

Integrations and Apps

Imagine these ecommerce platforms as your favorite smartphone, loaded with apps to make your life easier. Here is the large volume of integrations and apps that you can dive into.

Exploring the Range of Integrations and Apps Available for BigCommerce

The BigCommerce App Store boasts a diverse range of integrations and apps, catering to various business needs. Whether you're into email marketing, analytics, or inventory management, there's an app for that. BigCommerce even offers integration with popular ecommerce platforms like Amazon, helping you cast a wider net to reel in customers.

But here's the kicker – while BigCommerce has an impressive selection, it's all about quality, not quantity. The integrations are vetted for compatibility, so you don't have to worry about your ecommerce toolbox turning into a chaotic junk drawer.

Analyzing the App Store and Integrations Ecosystem of Shopify

Shopify app store is like a treasure trove of possibilities, and it's growing faster than a rabbit on roller skates. You'll find apps for everything from SEO optimization to order tracking and beyond. Whether you're a small business owner or a tech-savvy entrepreneur, there's something in the Shopify App Store to help you level up your ecommerce game.

But with great choice comes great responsibility. While Shopify's app ecosystem offers immense versatility, you'll want to tread carefully. Make sure you choose apps that align with your business goals and don't go overboard – too many apps can slow down your store.

Performance and Speed

Performance isn't just a buzzword – it's the secret sauce that keeps customers coming back.

Evaluating the Performance and Loading Speed of BigCommerce Stores

Performance isn't just a buzzword – it's the secret sauce that keeps customers coming back. BigCommerce understands this, and it doesn't want your store to suffer from slow-loading syndrome. It offers robust hosting, ensuring that your store loads like lightning, even during peak shopping hours. And remember, speed isn't just about user experience; it's also a crucial factor for SEO rankings. Google doesn't like slowpokes, and neither do your customers.

Analyzing the Performance Benchmarks and Speed Optimizations of Shopify

Shopify doesn't want you to lose precious seconds, either. It provides performance benchmarks and speed optimizations to keep your store in top form. With its content delivery network (CDN) and responsive design, your store will be as fast as a Formula 1 car on the ecommerce racetrack.

Support and Resources

Picture this: you're on a tightrope, and you need a safety net. That's where customer support comes in, and BigCommerce wants to be your safety net. It offers a range of customer support options, including email, chat, and phone support.

Plus, it provides priority support for higher-tier plans, ensuring that you get the assistance you need when you need it most. BigCommerce also offers an extensive knowledge base and community forums where you can find answers to common questions and connect with other ecommerce enthusiasts.

Similarly, Shopify understands that sometimes you need a helping hand, and sometimes you just want to connect with fellow entrepreneurs who have been there, and done that. That's why it offers a robust ecosystem of support resources, including 24/7 customer support via chat, email, and phone. But that's not all – Shopify has a thriving community of users and experts in its forums and online communities. Whether you're looking for technical assistance or just some friendly advice, Shopify's got your back.

Security and Reliability

When it comes to ecommerce, you need a digital fortress to protect your precious data and customer information

Evaluating the Security Measures and Protocols Implemented by BigCommerce

When it comes to ecommerce, you need a digital fortress to protect your precious data and customer information. BigCommerce knows this and has a robust security setup to keep cyber troublemakers at bay. They employ industry-standard security protocols, including SSL certificates, to encrypt sensitive data during transactions. Plus, BigCommerce is PCI DSS compliant, which means they adhere to the highest standards of payment security. It's like having a team of digital bouncers guarding your online storefront.

Analyzing the Reliability and Uptime Guarantees of Shopify

Just like you wouldn't open a brick-and-mortar store in a neighborhood known for power outages, Shopify doesn't want your online store to face downtime. They offer an impressive 99.99% uptime guarantee, ensuring your store is open for business virtually 24/7. This high level of reliability is like having a superhero sidekick ensuring your online presence remains rock-solid.

Choosing the Perfect Platform for Your Business

In the ultimate showdown between BigCommerce and Shopify, there's no one-size-fits-all winner. Your choice depends on your unique needs, budget, and goals. Both platforms offer a formidable arsenal of tools and features, and it's up to you to decide which one aligns best with your vision.

So, whether you ride with BigCommerce or gallop with Shopify, remember that your ecommerce journey is an epic adventure. The digital frontier awaits, and your success story is just a few clicks away.

As you embark on your ecommerce journey, don't forget that the Triple Whale Summary dashboard is your secret weapon for conquering the digital frontier.

Saddle up, entrepreneurs – it's time to conquer the ecommerce world!

Learn More About Summary Today!

Happy selling! 💪


© Triple Whale Inc.
266 N 5th Street, Columbus OH 43209