How Levain Bakery tests new channels with a single source of truth in Triple Whale

Levain Bakery cut reporting time 20% and shifted 12% of its media budget to higher-efficiency channels with Triple Whale.

Levain Bakery is a New York City bakery known for its six-ounce cookies. Pam Weekes and Connie McDonald founded it in 1995 as a small bread shop on Manhattan’s Upper West Side. While training for triathlons, they made a large chocolate chip walnut cookie that quickly sold out.

The company runs its paid media with an agency partner. Shianne Smalling, Levain’s Senior Growth Marketing Manager, works on email, SMS, and retention, and on paid media alongside Angela Mao, a digital marketing manager at Deodato.

A new test cost Levain its best channel’s budget

Levain Bakery sees adding new paid channels as essential to its growth. Each new channel test has to answer one question: Is the channel adding orders, or only claiming them?

In Q4 of 2025, one of the new channels they tested looked like a clear win. On its own platform, the new channel appeared incremental and more efficient than Levain Bakery’s most mature channel. Platform-reported metrics and Shopify data were Levain’s source of truth at the time (both of which they trusted), so the team moved spend from their biggest channel to the new channel.

But the gap between platform-reported orders and last-click data was hard to miss.

Angela saw the same issues across Deodato’s work. Every platform counts conversions in its own way, and one she described takes about 90% of its orders from impressions, with no click data. Comparing channels on equal terms was nearly impossible.

Why Levain Bakery picked Triple Whale for AI-powered attribution

Levain Bakery needed a complete operating system to serve as their source of truth and deliver unbiased attribution, so it began looking at Triple Whale and other vendors. They considered four criteria when making their decision: cost, how long the vendor had been in business, how many people used it, and how well it met Levain Bakery’s needs.

Today, she, her colleagues, and the Deodato team use Moby to build dashboards, set up daily reports, and check new channels before they get more budget, something Triple Whale’s trusted attribution numbers give them more confidence in executing.

"It just makes us have so much confidence to propose and pitch out new channels, knowing that we have Triple Whale in the backend that will help us give a very accurate read on the incrementality of the new channel in the testing phase."
Angela MaoDigital Marketing ManagerDeodato

Ask Moby AI instead of building reports by hand

Before Triple Whale, getting a fuller email performance picture meant manually joining Google Analytics and Klaviyo data with VLOOKUPs. With Moby, Levain built an email dashboard that combines Klaviyo platform data with last-click revenue attribution, with no waiting on reports and no manual stitching.

“Moby AI is like having a data analyst and a media strategist all in one platform.”
Shianne SmallingSenior Growth Marketing ManagerLevain Bakery

On the agency side, Angela used Moby to set up automated daily reports from Triple Whale to a Google Sheet. Deodato layers Triple Whale's attribution for each channel over its own channel-level reporting and compares the two side by side. When a week shows a large gap, the team looks into the cause.

Use Moby AI for performance questions

Shianne compared Moby with general AI tools like Claude and ChatGPT, noting that data access is the key difference. Moby works on Levain Bakery's performance data, so she doesn't have to move it into another tool first.

"Claude and ChatGPT don't have or understand the relationship between our different datasets, what they mean, and why they're important. And that impacts how meaningful the outputs are.”
Shianne SmallingSenior Growth Marketing ManagerLevain Bakery

Results: Faster reporting and a clearer read on each channel

Triple Whale now serves more than paid media. The digital product manager, the paid media team, and Shianne's email work all draw from it, and Deodato can pitch a new channel with one consistent read on its incrementality.

Beyond the dashboards and reports, Shianne sees Moby as part of the team.

"It's like having another built-in teammate to bounce ideas off of and get information from.”
Shianne SmallingSenior Growth Marketing ManagerLevain Bakery
  • “The unlocks Triple Whale has given us in terms of the speed of reporting have been invaluable. Having that one singular place that we’re all using to pull our data has been really helpful.”
    Shianne SmallingSenior Growth Marketing Manager